Contents
- What happened
- How the scientists noticed
- What the scientists saw
- Was it coercion?
- Why it surprised the scientists
- What science says about same-sex behaviour
- Why far-reaching conclusions can't be drawn
- What benefit the authors see
- How animals make friends
- Why animals shouldn't be kept alone
- Donkeys and their bonds
- Is it dangerous to keep a bull and a horse on the same pasture?
- What sexual behaviour means for a vet
- How animals show attachment
- Why stories like this go viral
- Why behavioural science matters
- Livestock farming in Ethiopia
- How to observe your own animals
- How to tell animals are happy together
- What this means for Europe
- When to see a vet
What happened
On 2 November 2026 the journal Current Biology published work by scientists at the University of Pisa on the rare behaviour of two animals in Ethiopia, a bull named Achille and a donkey named Patroclo. The names refer to heroes of the Trojan War. The Guardian and other outlets wrote about the study, and the news quickly spread across social media.
The animals had different owners and met only on a shared pasture when their herds were grazing side by side. The scientists described how they found each other, licked and rubbed against each other, and how the bull repeatedly had sexual contact with the donkey.
Current Biology; November 2026
How the scientists noticed
PhD student André da Cruz says the scientists spotted the pair by chance during a lunch break while studying gelada monkeys. He told colleagues he thought he'd seen the bull mount the donkey, and they didn't believe him. The scientists then began watching the animals on purpose, for four days when both were grazing nearby and four days when only one of them was there.
What the scientists saw
Other donkeys tried to avoid the bull and made threatening facial expressions. Patroclo, by contrast, presented his hindquarters and went up to Achille himself. Licking and scratching often came before and, especially interestingly, after contact. According to the authors, it looks as if this contact helps prolong the time they spend together, rather than being linked only with sexual arousal.
Was it coercion?
Co-author Elisabetta Palagi says she saw no sign of coercion. In her words, the animals sought each other out. When Achille went up to someone else on the plateau, Patroclo came closer and tried to distract him. Da Cruz also believes the bull's behaviour can hardly be explained by simple dominance. The donkey, meanwhile, was aggressive towards other bulls.
Why it surprised the scientists
Palagi calls the case very unusual and says something like this has been described for the first time. Neither the bull nor the donkey tried to mount animals of their own species, although they had the chance, and the bull courted some cows. Contact between species has been reported before, for instance between snow monkeys and female sika deer, but there was usually no mutual interest in those cases.
What science says about same-sex behaviour
Same-sex behaviour has been described in more than 1,500 animal species. A 2023 study found it in 261 mammal species and linked it above all with social species, where such contact probably helps maintain relationships and settle conflicts. As a primatologist writes in The Conversation, in bonobos it's a normal part of life. So for biologists the fact itself is no sensation, and what's unusual is the combination of species.
Why far-reaching conclusions can't be drawn
The scientists watched the animals for only four days, so it isn't known how long their relationship lasted or how it began. Nor can human ideas about love be applied to animals. The authors speak of a special relationship and journalists of a romance, but the work is about observed behaviour. Longer observation and other cases are needed before drawing conclusions about the causes.
What benefit the authors see
Palagi believes the animals get attention, contact and possibly protection from such relationships. She says that when two individuals of the same or different species need a special relationship, they use their whole behavioural repertoire. It isn't clear which came first, sexual or social interest, or whether they can be separated at all.
How animals make friends
Bonds between species often occur without any sexual behaviour. Horses make friends with goats and donkeys, dogs with cats, and in sanctuaries cows become attached to dogs and people. Herd animals are especially prone to this: loneliness is hard on them, and when there are no others of their kind they find another companion. People enjoy these stories, but there's a serious biological need behind them.
Why animals shouldn't be kept alone
Horses, donkeys, cows, sheep and goats are herd animals. Loneliness causes them chronic stress, restlessness and health problems. The laws of some countries explicitly require horses and donkeys to be kept in company. If you have one donkey, it needs a companion, preferably another donkey, as mixed pairs don't always replace their own kind, especially when working.
Donkeys and their bonds
Donkeys are known for especially strong pair bonds. Separating a pair can cause an animal deep distress and even a dangerous loss of appetite, leading to metabolic disorders. So when one of a pair is sold or dies, vets advise thinking ahead about how to support the other. Some donkeys are helped by seeing their dead companion and staying with it for a while.
Is it dangerous to keep a bull and a horse on the same pasture?
Keepers should know that a large bull can seriously injure a smaller animal, even without aggression. So mixed grazing isn't always safe. A bull's horns and weight, and differences in behaviour and feeding, call for supervision. Different species also have different parasites and diseases, and feed for one can harm another: some cattle supplements are dangerous to horses, for example.
What sexual behaviour means for a vet
If an animal constantly mounts others, is in pain or has wounds, this may be a behaviour or health problem. A vet will check for hormonal disorders, injuries, pain and overcrowding. Another consequence can be injuries that become an entry point for infection. Castration often resolves these conflicts.
How animals show attachment
Mutual grooming, seeking closeness, play and standing calmly together are considered signs of a bond. You may notice such pairs in your own herd. It's worth taking these friendships into account when transporting, treating and regrouping animals, as separated friends eat less well and are more nervous. Sometimes the mere presence of a familiar animal makes treatment easier.
Why stories like this go viral
Stories of friendship and love between different species spread easily on social media, as they make people smile and talk. But viral videos often show only part of the truth. What looks like play or love is sometimes really stress or coercion. The value of this work is that the scientists recorded behaviour systematically and compared different days, rather than simply filming a clip.
Why behavioural science matters
Observations like these help us understand how animals communicate and what they need. This knowledge is used in zoos, on farms and in shelters, in choosing groups, organising pastures and working on behaviour. A good understanding of social bonds reduces stress and fighting, and ultimately makes animals' lives better.
Livestock farming in Ethiopia
Ethiopia is among the African countries with the largest livestock populations, and animals often graze freely and mixed together on common land. This is what allowed a bull and a donkey with different owners to meet every day. The same conditions make it easier for diseases to pass between species, so vets in these areas do a lot of work with owners on vaccination and tick control.
How to observe your own animals
It's useful just to watch your herd from time to time: who stands with whom, who chases whom away, who eats last. It's a simple, free way to spot problems. An animal that suddenly keeps away from the others or stops seeking out a familiar companion may be ill. Note down anything unusual and show your vet a video, as this makes it easier to assess behaviour.
How to tell animals are happy together
Friends graze side by side, don't chase each other away from food and rest calmly next to each other. If one animal keeps running away or is losing weight, it's better to separate the pair.
What this means for Europe
Mixed pastures are becoming more popular in Europe, as horses, donkeys and cows use grass differently when grazing together. The Italian scientists' work is a reminder that complex relationships form between animals and should be taken into account when organising groups. It's also a reminder for European keepers that herd animals shouldn't live alone.
When to see a vet
See your vet if an animal becomes lame, has wounds, swollen genitals or bleeding after contact, or if it stops eating after being separated from its companion. Loss of appetite is especially dangerous in donkeys: a serious metabolic disorder can start within a couple of days, so call the vet immediately rather than waiting until morning.
Sources
- The Guardian, 2 November 2026
- The Conversation, 2 November 2026










