Pet diaryDiaryMemorial page
Law

A racing star in a skip: the body of a Melbourne Cup runner has been found at a Sydney tip, and his owner is demanding an inquiry

A scandal has erupted in Australia over the gelding So You Are, who finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup on 3 November. After the race he fell ill, surgery failed and he was put to sleep under anaesthetic. His body was found in an open skip at a landfill site in Sydney, where it was awaiting burial. The footage outraged both the racing industry and animal welfare campaigners. The veterinary hospital has apologised and the state government has promised to look into it. Why horse carcasses can't be disposed of like ordinary rubbish, and how it works in Europe.

9 min read
A bay horse in a bridle standing by a fence in a field
Photo: Freepik
Contents
  1. What happened
  2. The horse's journey
  3. The body in a skip
  4. What the owner says
  5. The authorities' response
  6. The regulator's account
  7. The hospital apologises
  8. The owner isn't satisfied
  9. How horses are usually buried
  10. Why a carcass can't be left exposed
  11. Danger to scavengers
  12. Why there are so many horses
  13. The New Zealand example
  14. Animal welfare campaigners
  15. Euthanasia in horses
  16. Options for saying goodbye
  17. What this means for Europe
  18. The rules in Europe
  19. The horse passport
  20. Racing and horse welfare
  21. What racehorses suffer from
  22. Advice for horse owners
  23. Dogs and carcasses
  24. A veterinary hospital at the centre of the scandal
  25. What the footage shows
  26. Public feeling
  27. What happens next
  28. When to call a vet

What happened

On 17 November a scandal broke in Australia over the death of the racehorse So You Are. The body of the five-year-old gelding, who had recently run in the country's most famous race, was found in an open skip at a landfill site in Sydney. A local resident filmed it, and the footage quickly spread online.

The horse's journey

So You Are, trained by Bjorn Baker, finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup on 3 November. After the race he was sent to a farm for a spell, where he fell ill. He underwent surgery, but it couldn't save him, and the gelding was put to sleep under anaesthetic. This is standard practice when there's no chance of recovery.

The body in a skip

The horse's body was taken to Cleanaway's Lucas Heights landfill site in Sydney, which is licensed to bury dead horses. There it lay in an open skip awaiting burial. That's when a visitor to the site filmed it. The images outraged both people in the racing industry and opponents of racing.

What the owner says

The horse's owner and breeder, Stuart Ramsey, who runs Turangga Farm in the Hunter Valley, called it a disgrace and demanded a full investigation. “He was more than a racehorse. He brought our family together,” Ramsey said. He said about thirty family members and friends had travelled to the Melbourne Cup.

Key factsThe gelding So You Are
5age of the gelding in yearsThe Guardian
8thplace in the Melbourne Cup on 3 NovemberThe Guardian
8career winsThe Guardian
1.4 millionAustralian dollars in prize moneyThe Guardian
2 mminimum soil cover over a buried carcassNSW Department of Primary Industries

The Guardian; 17 November 2026

The authorities' response

New South Wales premier Chris Minns said the case needed to be investigated and all the circumstances established. “We do need better ways of disposing of horses,” he added. The racing regulator, Racing NSW, has opened an inquiry.

The regulator's account

According to Racing NSW, the body was being held temporarily at the landfill pending burial when the video was filmed. In other words, the horse was going to be buried according to the rules, but the conditions in which the body was kept were unacceptable. The inquiry is meant to establish who was responsible at each stage.

The hospital apologises

The veterinary hospital that treated the horse has apologised to the owners and trainer. Its managing partner, Jonathan Lumsden, said the hospital didn't bury the horse itself but takes full responsibility for its choice of contractor. “He should have been buried quickly and with dignity,” he said.

The owner isn't satisfied

Ramsey wasn't satisfied with these explanations. He said the hospital was responsible for the horse and should have offered to let the owners bury the gelding on their stud farm. He believes the managers who made the decisions should be held accountable, not just the contractor.

How horses are usually buried

In Australia, vets usually send horse carcasses to licensed landfill sites that accept such remains. This is what the state's Department of Primary Industries recommends. The carcass must be transported covered and buried under at least two metres of soil, at a safe distance from water sources.

Why a carcass can't be left exposed

It's not just a matter of respect for the animal. The drugs used for euthanasia break down slowly and are toxic to other animals. As Charles Sturt University veterinary researcher Cathrynne Henshall points out, they can persist in tissue for years and leach into the soil.

Danger to scavengers

If the body of a euthanised horse is left in the open, dogs, foxes, birds and other scavengers may eat it. They then take in a dose of the drug and can die. Cases of dogs and birds of prey being poisoned after eating carcasses of euthanised animals have been described in various countries. So proper disposal also protects wildlife.

Why there are so many horses

Australia's racing industry is one of the largest in the world. Every year thousands of horses die or are put down for various reasons. Specialists note that many of them end up at landfill sites. So You Are's case attracted attention because he was a famous horse.

The New Zealand example

New Zealand has already had a similar scandal, when a horse's body was also dumped at a tip. After an investigation, a dedicated horse crematorium run by a charitable trust was set up. It opened in 2025. Now owners and vets can have horses cremated with dignity.

Animal welfare campaigners

Animal welfare organisations have demanded action from the authorities and the racing industry. In their view, the scandal shows that horses' welfare is looked after while they make money, but after death they're treated as waste. Racing organisations respond that most horses receive good care.

Euthanasia in horses

Putting a horse to sleep is a hard decision, but sometimes the only humane one in the case of incurable illness or serious injury. It is carried out by a vet: first a sedative is given, then a drug that painlessly stops the heart. Owners should know in advance what will happen to the body afterwards.

Options for saying goodbye

Horse owners can choose between burial, where permitted, cremation and handing the body over to a specialist disposal service. Cremation is more expensive but allows the ashes to be kept. Many owners would like to bury their horse where it lived, but that isn't possible everywhere.

What this means for Europe

In the EU, horse carcasses are classed as animal by-products. They are usually sent for rendering or incinerated at specialist plants. Burial on your own land is only allowed in certain cases and not in every country. The rules are strict precisely because of drug residues and the risk of disease.

The rules in Europe

In many EU countries owners must report a horse's death and call a fallen stock service, which collects the body. Some countries have horse cemeteries and crematoriums. Before buying a horse it's worth finding out the local rules, so you don't have to look for a solution in a hurry at a difficult moment.

The horse passport

In the EU every horse has a passport stating whether it may enter the food chain. If a horse has received certain medicines, it is permanently excluded from meat production. After euthanasia, the body of such a horse must in any case go only for disposal.

Racing and horse welfare

Every year the Melbourne Cup is accompanied by debate about horse welfare: horses have died in the race in past years. Organisers have tightened pre-race veterinary checks. But So You Are's story shows that responsibility for a horse doesn't end at the finishing line.

What racehorses suffer from

After a hard race, horses are prone to colic, leg injuries, breathing problems and dehydration. Colic can develop suddenly and require emergency surgery. Even with good care, some of these cases end in death. The cause of So You Are's illness has not been officially stated.

Advice for horse owners

  1. Discuss with your vet in advance what to do in an emergency.
  2. Find out the local rules on burial and cremation.
  3. Keep the contact details of a fallen stock service to hand.
  4. Don't leave a horse's body exposed to other animals.
  5. Ask your vet to explain all the options for saying goodbye.

Dogs and carcasses

Dog owners should remember that if a dog finds an animal carcass on a walk, it should be led away immediately. A carcass may contain euthanasia drugs, bacteria or parasites. Poisoning shows as weakness, unsteadiness and drowsiness and needs urgent treatment.

A veterinary hospital at the centre of the scandal

Hospitals that treat racehorses usually arrange transport and burial of bodies with contractors themselves. Owners often don't know exactly where their horse has been taken. So You Are's case showed that nobody really checks this stage, and the industry is now discussing how to make it transparent.

What the footage shows

In the video filmed by a visitor to the site, the horse's body lies in an open metal skip among other waste. It was the exposure and the sight of the remains that caused outrage. Under the rules the body should be covered and buried quickly, not left in full view of visitors.

Public feeling

For many Australians the Melbourne Cup is a national celebration, “the race that stops a nation”. That's why the story of a runner in that race ending up in a skip caused such a stir. It made many people think about what happens to racehorses after their careers end and after they die.

What happens next

Racing NSW and the New South Wales government are continuing their investigation. It may lead to tighter rules on transporting and storing horse carcasses at landfill sites. The racing industry is discussing setting up its own dignified disposal service, following New Zealand's example.

When to call a vet

If your horse becomes restless after exercise, paws the ground, lies down and rolls, sweats for no reason or refuses food, call your vet immediately: it may be colic. If your dog eats something from an animal carcass and becomes lethargic or unsteady, take it to the vet urgently.

Sources

  1. The Guardian, 17 November 2026
Topic: LawAnimals: HorsesCountry: Australia